This past week has been a good one following my Enbrel shot last Thursday. I woke up on Friday morning with no stiffness, no fatigue and very little pain. The trouble is I don’t know whether to shout out loud ‘hooray’ or whether this is just coincidence..always erring on the side of caution me..The week progressed much the same and life has improved I’ve found myself doing more and more without thinking about it ..always a sure sign that your feeling better. By Wednesday I had a slight twinges in my hands and wrists and was actually looking forward to my 2nd shot. My meds this week had been 1 x 50mg Enbrel shot and 3mg Prednislone a day. No painkillers.
That brings me on to the next part of this post…expectations. What are my expectations and are they realistic. Everyone seems to have a different idea on whether a med is working or whether they are in remission, by that I mean clinical remission.
A recent article in Arthritis today gives the following criteria: http://www.arthritistoday.org/news/rheumatoid-arthritis-remission115.php
One definition says to be considered in remission, patients need to meet four goals:
1. One or less swollen joints
2. One or less tender joints
3. An assessment by the patient that on a zero-to-10 scale, the arthritis activity is one or less
4. A blood test showing little or no inflammation in their levels of C-reactive protein, a key biomarker of inflammation
Whilst the American college of rheumatology list the following:
The American College of Rheumatology (ARC) classification criteria for determining clinical remission include:
1. morning stiffness less than or equal to 15 minutes
2. no fatigue
3. no joint pain
4. no joint tenderness or pain on motion
5. no soft tissue swelling in joints or tendon sheaths
6. erythrocyte sedimentation rate less than or equal to 30 in females and 20 in males
My expectations are high...my goal is remission, maybe that is unrealistic but I would like to be able to live my life without constantly being reminded by pain, stiffness and fatigue that I have this illness. However in reality I have had RA for 23 years and of course have some joint damage, my right wrist is partially fused and my left is trying to join the party, my metatarsals in my feet are damaged and so I often have some foot pain. Now, again looking at me I use my hands perfectly well and walk just fine at a brisk pace, unless of course I'm in a flare, to the casual observer I'm fine. But my point is that with this amount of joint damage I am not likely to meet either of the above criteria to say I'm in clinical remission. But does that mean I wont be? Does that mean that any one with joint damage cannot achieve clinical remission? And then again, should I lower my expectations to avoid disappointment if this drug does not live up to the hype? Dont get me wrong the most important outcome is that I feel well but somehow by joining the remission club I would feel like I'd won.
Now for me if in 3 months time I still have pain and swelling on Enbrel I would consider it was not working. Would I want to add another highly toxic drug to make a cocktail....no....I dont think I would, maybe I'm not brave enough, I would prefer to try another in the hope that I could achieve some sort of remission on monotherapy. Surely double the toxicity..double the risk. I may be totally wrong on this, this view is just my own and that may well change as I tread the boilogic path, who knows. I know that the general concensus is that Anti TNF therapy works best in conjunction with Methotrexate but for me that is just a pill too far. I know many people reading this will be on combination therapy and I am not saying your choices are wrong...you made them for your own reasons dictated by your own health and disease activity and therefore they are the right choices for you in your bid to beat this debilitating illness. I have been afraid of every single medication I have been prescribed for this illness, justified I feel by my reaction to sulfasalazine, and I know that when you get to the point that the pain is just too much to bear in reality you will try anything.....
Please, please, please leave your comments, tell me and others what you think and what your experiences are it is only by sharing our own thoughts and stories that we will all learn and become educated enough to fight our own battle against RA.
Thanks for sharing your experiences! I'm glad you were able to do the Enbrel shot yourself. Surprisingly, my doc didn't make me do even the first shot with a nurse...just said, here you go! I found Enbrel to be extremely helpful...even when I switched to go on Humira, I know that Enbrel was still doing me a great deal of good. You'll get used to the auto-injector to some degree; doesn't mean it's easy to press the button (unless you're masochistic, perhaps!), but if it works the 10 seconds of stinging is more than worth it :) For most of my time on Enbrel I was on it as a monotherapy -- and I was probably borderline in clinical remission on and off for a time. I hope it works just as well for you! My goal is true remission, but that's looking pretty lofty!
ReplyDeleteI'm curious to hear about your wrists. My doctor says he's concerned that my wrists may fuse - but I don't know how quickly that can happen or *what* really is happening. I just know that the joint space is narrowing and I have pain, stiffness, limited range of motion and inflammation. That's really the reason we've been looking at new drug options... How well do you function with your wrist that's partially fused?
Best of luck and blessings to you, Barbara!
Hi Dana My right wrist has been partially fused for the last 20 years, since then it has not got any worse from the point of moving but some tissue thickening has developed. The fusing happened over a period of a year of two. If not in a flare I can use it very well, it doesn't stop me doing anything but if I over use it then it aches and I need to rest it. I can still move it in all directions to a degree. The left wrist still has almost full movement but is probably at the stage yours are at now...Hope this helps..Good Luck with Humira ..hang on to your goals its what we are all aiming for.
DeleteHi Barb, First off, Thank you for your blog. I think it will help so many of us who suffer from RAD and are going through the beginnings of Biologic tx, as you are. I pray for you that Enbrel will be the answer to your 23 year battle w/ the pain & suffering you've endured. I was diagnosed with RAD in 1986...since no Biologics or DMARD's were available then I suffered a great deal over the course of the next 10-12 years before I was started on Enbrel in ~1999 (I can't remember the actual year that Biologics came about & lose track of when I started exactly) I had also been on a low dose Prednisone too. By this time, both of my wrists had fused totally along with my Rt. ankle, which is with up & down range of motion only. I have to say if it wasn't for these Biologics, I feel the RA destruction and fusion would of continued in my other joints. I truly feel that my faith & positive thinking has also brought me where I am at today. Thank God that it is only my wrists that are totally fused- I function very well without the range of motion in them..however, they still do ache from time to time and if I accidentally "bump" them-It sends me to my knees in excruciating "lightning Bolts" of pain. I realize it's something I could, but had to live with at this point. I was on Enbrel weekly & pred. daily for several years and then when Humira first came out, I was excited to try it, since it meant no more weekly injections but every 2 week injections. My doc at the time said it was up to me and that it was a gamble.. but I was willing to take the risk just because I wanted that wonderful regime of every 2 weeks. I am one of the lucky ones that took that risk and had the same, positive results that the Enbrel had and to this day. I understand fully your hesitation of adding yet another "toxic" drug to your regime such as Methotrexate. I am at that stage right now, I stopped the Mtx prior to my foot reconstruction surgery last month, I had been on it for the past year and hated how I felt, tons of hair loss but more importantly, I couldn't take the extreme fatigue I had while taking it. Well, I'm taking that gamble again and staying off of it, in hopes that I will prevail on just the Humira alone, with the occasional Ibuprofen. I will see how it goes... Thank you again Barb and I look forward to reading more from you. Best of luck and I'll be rooting for you in your quest for that "Monotherapy" remission on Enbrel. xo
ReplyDeleteThank you Therese for leaving your story here..I wish more people would share ..it really does help
ReplyDelete